One thing that I've learned since I started getting serious about birding is that photographing them is really hard. In addition to all the usual technical challenges to taking a good photograph (exposure, focus, field of view, background, etc) birds are by nature uncooperative subjects. They refuse to sit still while you try to frame your shot, they like to hide in thick brush or tree branches so your autofocus gets confused, and above all, they just plain don't like people getting close to them!
The first two problems you can overcome by selecting your location and by being fast with your focusing and shutter release. But the third, that birds are skittish and tend to not let you get close, is a much harder issue to work around. If your camera doesn't have a powerful enough optical zoom then your only recourse is to use a high megapixel capture with good image stabilization or tripod and hope you have enough pixels to crop down from. This is the technique I've been using for many of the birding posts on this blog and, to be honest, it leaves a lot to be desired.
So, after some serious online research and borrowing a DSLR from a friend for a two week hands-on test drive (thanks bud - you rock!) I broke down and bought a new camera for birding: a Canon PowerShot SX10 IS. It's no DSLR - although it sort of looks like one - but it's got the long optical zoom that I need to get good close-up shots. And at $360 on Amazon it didn't break the bank, which is what the DSLR + telephoto lens would've done.
The pictures, while obviously not DSLR quality, are bright and clear and at the long end of the zoom (an astounding 560mm 35mm-equivalent) you can reach out and fill the frame with a small bird a hundred feet way. The zoom is unbelievably powerful for such a relatively small package. Some of the shots I've taken I would've previously thought required a full-on digiscoping rig to accomplish. It just has to be seen to be believed.
I've had the camera out in the field three times now and am so far very happy with the results. You've already seen a few birding photos taken with it in the previous couple of posts. The bright yellow male Lesser Goldfinch shot was taken at 150+ feet and cropped a bit and the results were pretty good, way better than my Canon SD790IS could have ever done. And the juvenile Robin was about 40 feet away and the bird almost filled the frame. Not bad. Not bad at all.
I'm very impressed with the performance of this camera, although it does have a few drawbacks. But I guess that's to be expected as it's not a professional, or even a prosumer level camera. Here's my list of pros and cons with an eye towards the birder:
Pros:
- Incredibly long 20x zoom lens allows you to get close to the birds without having to physically approach them. The IS (image stabilization) is very good and allows you to take full zoom photos without a tripod as long as the light is halfway decent.
- Uses AA batteries, so if you're on a trip and your batteries get low you can buy more at any convenience store. This adds weight to the camera but even with the 4 AAs the camera isn't all that heavy.
- The 28mm wide-end of the lens allows you to get more scenery into your pictures. I can't wait to get this camera up to the top of Humphreys and put it through its paces.
- Fast power-on and fast zooming so you can be up and zoomed in in only a second or so. This is good if you're hiking along and you suddenly see a life-bird fly over.
- Autofocus and autoexposure are pretty fast and accurate. I've only had a couple instances where the autofocus "hunted" and that was in a relatively dark scene.
- Full auto for us beginning photographers as well as all the usual manual settings for the more advanced ones.
- The LCD is bright and can be used in full daylight even while wearing dark sunglasses.
- Relatively cheap at $360 on Amazon, especially when compared to a DSLR body + expensive telephoto lens.
- Relatively light, especially when compared to a DSLR + heavy telephoto lens.
Cons:
- The lens is pretty slow at the long end - f5.7 is about all you get. The image stabilization helps a lot with this, though. Still, you're going to need decent light to keep your shutter speed up enough to avoid camera shake. This is the trade-off you make for a lighter and cheaper lens.
- There's some noticeable purple fringing in high contrast areas near the periphery of the frames when zoomed. From my research I understand that this is an artifact of the lens not having as much glass in it as more expensive telephoto DSLR lenses.
- The higher ISO settings exhibit some digital noise.
- At the wide 28mm end the lens exhibits a little barrel distortion.
- The electronic viewfinder is kinda small and needs some getting used to. I've found that you can look across the top of the flash hot shoe like a gun sight, though.
- The lens cap included with the camera is super cheap and falls off easily. The first thin I did after I got the camera was buy a replacement cap with a lanyard at BestBuy. Get the 52mm one.
- The neck strap is also kind of cheap but it works well enough. I'll get around to replacing it some time but for now I'm living with it.
From an amateur photographer and birders perspective I think the Canon PowerShot SX10 IS is a great camera for a decent price. Honestly, I've taken more good bird pictures in the past two weeks than I did in the entire first half of the year with my other camera. The zoom power of this camera makes all the difference. Without dropping a whole lot more money on a digiscoping rig or a DSLR+telephoto lens I don't think I could've done much better. If it can stand up to the rigors of the trail and riding in my day pack then I expect that I'll be spending a lot of quality time with this camera over the next couple of years.
EDIT 8/19/2009: It figures that two weeks after I buy the SX10 IS Canon would announce the PowerShot SX20 IS. Sheesh. I'd still buy the SX10 IS in an instant, though.